Can the U.S. Economy Be
"Strong" While the Housing Market Has Collapsed?
By the Curmudgeon with Victor
Sperandeo
U.S. Economic Week in Review:
ท
The National Federation of
Independent Businesses (NFIB) Small Business Optimism Index ticked down from
97.9 to 97.8 as attitudes were largely unchanged. However, the net percentage
of owners planning to raise prices in the coming months jumped, revealing
significant inflationary pressure.
ท
The Consumer Price Index
(CPI) came in hotter than expected for October. Official year-over-year figures
are not available as the October 2025 datapoint was not released due to the
prolonged government shutdown. Using the September and November data to
extrapolate an October figure, however, we see that overall CPI rose 3.9% on an
annual basis and the Core CPI rose 2.8% both well above the Feds 2%
inflation target.
ท
The Producer Price Index
(PPI) jumped 6.5% year-over-year in October as price pressures further up the
supply chain continued to be significant.
ท
Existing-home sales fell by
5.5% in October 2026 to a seasonally adjusted annual rate of 3.75 million
units, reaching their lowest level since August 2010 when the housing market
was still reeling from the aftermath of the Great Financial Crisis.
..
From the National Association of REALTORSฎ Existing-Home Sales
Report:
ท
Existing-home sales decreased
8.8% Year over Year (YoY).
ท
Total housing inventory
climbed to 1.59 million units, a 5.1-month supply.
ท
Unsold inventory represented
a 5.1-month supply, up from 4.7 months in September and 4.4 months in October
2025.
ท
Month-over-month sales
declined in the Midwest, South and West and held steady in the Northeast. YoY
sales declined in all four regions.
ท
The Housing Affordability
Index registered at 100.7, down from 107.3 one year ago.
ท
Housing affordability
declined in all four regions YoY (Northeast: down 8.7%, Midwest: down 7.2%,
South: down 5.4%, West: down 5.2%)
NAR Chief Economist Lawrence Yun noted, Home buying is
difficult when mortgage rates have climbed to their highest levels since 2000,
aside from a single month in 2023. As a result, home sales fell to their lowest
level since August 2010.
The Wall Street
Journal (subscription required) reported on Friday: Real-estate agents and
mortgage lenders have reported that since then, open houses have gone quiet and
buyers have stopped their search. A year
expected to herald the housing markets resurgence is instead drawing to a
close on a dour note. Goldman Sachs Research economists forecast last month
just 3.9 million existing home sales in 2027, compared with well above 5
million before the pandemic. The last time sales for a calendar year came in
below 4 million was 1995.
Curmudgeon/Sperandeo Comment and Analysis:
Existing homes account for more than three-quarters of the
market, making this a critical signal that activity has ground to a halt. This is yet another report that shows the
housing market has collapsed and remains in a severe decline.
The housing industry is a classic leading indicator for the
U.S. economy, accounting for ~16% to 18% of GDP. Yet the powers that be claim
the economy is strong. That doesnt
seem possible!
In reality, the U.S. economy appears strong on the surface
largely due to the unprecedented debt-fueled AI and data center capex boom by
hyperscalers and frontier AI labs (like OpenAI and Anthropic)though heavy
hardware imports mean the direct domestic GDP boost is smaller than headline
spending suggests. Despite that anomaly, the economy cannot be truly strong
while home sales and residential construction remain severely depressed and
trending downward. That is clearly
depicted in this chart:

The housing market's severe stall is a significant warning
sign for the U.S. economy and equity markets:
Implications for the
U.S. Economy:
1. Economic slowdown: Housing weakness reduces economic
activity across construction, building materials, mortgage lending, real estate
services, furniture and appliances.
2. Consumer spending: High mortgage rates and housing costs
leave households with less disposable income, weakening discretionary
consumption.
3. Employment risk: Prolonged housing weakness could
eventually translate into reduced construction activity, layoffs and weaker
employment.
4. Recession signal: Housing is highly
interest-rate-sensitive and often an early indicator of broader economic
weakness.
Impact on U.S. Equity
Markets:
- Negative: Homebuilders, building-material suppliers, real
estate brokers, mortgage lenders and consumer discretionary companies.
- Broader market: Increasing risk of weaker corporate
earnings as economic activity and consumer spending soften.
- Interest rates: Markets may anticipate Fed rate cuts,
potentially supporting bonds and rate-sensitive equities. However, persistent
inflation could prevent meaningful monetary easing.
Bottom line: A stalled housing market is another indication that high
interest rates and deteriorating affordability are taking a toll on the U.S.
economy. It increases downside risks to corporate earnings and equity
valuations, particularly if housing weakness spreads into employment and
consumer spending.
Victors Economic and Market Outlook:
1. The Growing Risk of a Major Economic Downturn
Contrarian investor and well-respected author Doug Casey
forecasts that the U.S. economy is entering a "Greater Depression,"
driven by unsustainable sovereign debt, Federal Reserve money creation, and an
increasingly inflated artificial intelligence (AI) bubble. He expects this
downturn to be deeper, fundamentally different, and longer-lasting than the
19291946 Depression.
I believe Casey's forecast deserves serious consideration.
The extraordinary number of economic and financial risks now confronting the
U.S. is unlike anything I have seen in my lifetime.
2. Federal Reserve Policy, Rising Yields and Deflationary
Pressure
Gold, silver, Bitcoin, and nearly all commodities, excluding
crude oil and its refined products (like heating oil), are either at new lows
or approaching their lowest levels of 2026.
Meanwhile, the U.S. dollar (DXY index) is at a 19-month high. Treasury
bond prices are also nearing new lows (new highs in yields), reflecting renewed
upward pressure on interest rates.
This weakness accelerated following comments by Federal
Reserve Governor Christopher Waller on Tuesday, November 10. Waller suggested
that the Fed might have to raise interest rates by as much as 50 basis points
at its December 9 meeting. Waller was appointed by President Trump.
Wallers comments appear intended to reverse the recent rally
in Treasury prices (which had pushed yields lower) and reinforce expectations
of higher interest rates. The corresponding strength in the U.S. dollar, which
has closed at new highs, reflects this shift in market expectations. Why would Waller signal another substantial
rate increase? The traditional Federal Reserve approach to reducing inflation
is to slow economic activity by raising borrowing costs and suppressing
aggregate demand. In effect, the Fed attempts to bring inflation down by making
credit more expensive and weakening consumer and business spending.
The consequences could be particularly damaging given the
existing weakness in interest-sensitive sectors of the economy.
3. Housing Market: A Leading Indicator of Economic Weakness
Housing is leading the U.S. economy lower. This is especially
important because housing is highly sensitive to interest rates and represents
a substantial portion of household wealth and consumer economic activity. A prolonged housing downturn would have significant
consequences for construction, employment, consumer spending, and the broader
economy. Housing weakness is therefore an important warning signal for the U.S.
economic outlook.
4. Gold, Tether and Potential Additional Selling Pressure
One largely overlooked risk in the gold market involves Tether,
the stablecoin issuer that has become one of the largest gold buyers after
central banks and China.
Unlike traditional investments, Tether's stablecoin holdings
do not generate interest income. If declining Bitcoin prices and broader
cryptocurrency weakness lead Tether to liquidate some of its gold holdings,
that selling could add another source of downward pressure on gold prices.
This is a potential source of gold-market instability that
investors should not ignore.
5. Oil Prices, Iran and Washington's Changing Political
Priorities
Oil futures have declined approximately 14.5% from their June
highs. One explanation is that the Democrats' substantial victories in the
November 3rd elections have raised expectations of a possible change in Trump's
Iran policy, potentially shifting the administration toward negotiations and
peace. However, Im quite skeptical that
this will produce a lasting change.
Historically, Democratic administrations have initiated most
U.S. wars dating back to World War I, with the notable exception of the
Bush-Cheney Iraq War II. More fundamentally, the influence of defense
contractors over Congress makes a meaningful reduction in military commitments
unlikely. We no longer have a functioning Constitutional Republic in the
traditional sense.
The proposed increase in defense spending from $1 trillion to
$1.5 trillion reinforces this concern. Regardless of which party controls
Washington, the financial and political incentives supporting military spending
remain firmly entrenched.
The November 3rd election results could nevertheless produce
substantial changes in economic priorities, budget allocations, and
legislation. Trump has indicated that he intends to work with Democrats,
possibly in an effort to protect his political legacy. He has also softened his
position on immigration, recently telling 60
Minutes that he had been "too tough on immigration."
These political developments could influence financial
markets, particularly through changes in fiscal spending, taxation, regulation,
and government borrowing.
6. AI Spending, Technology Stocks and Emerging Credit Risks
After housing, GDP growth is critical to the U.S. economy.
However, equities represent the principal source of financial wealth for many
individual investors.
The technology sector, particularly AI-related capital spending (capex), has been one of the few major
positive forces supporting economic growth and equity valuations. That support
now appears to be weakening. AI capex growth will likely reach a major
peak this quarter. The challenge with a capex boom supporting earnings is
that keeping the same pace of earnings growth requires continued capex *growth*
at the same pace, explains Bob Elliott on Substack (subscription required).

Nvidia's stock has fallen from approximately $239 to $162, a
decline of roughly 32%. The decline has coincided with concerns surrounding the
company's leadership and broader questions about the sustainability of
AI-related valuations.
Hedgeyes Keith McCullough said 29 of 36 AI Stocks Are Signaling Bearish Trend in his November 13th market insights report.

Additional risks are emerging in private credit, including
problems involving CoreWeave and Blue Owl. Investors should ask how many other
undisclosed credit problems remain hidden in the rapidly expanding financing
ecosystem supporting AI infrastructure.
The semiconductor stock index (SOX) has also suffered a
substantial correction, falling from 14,634 on June 21 to 10,146, a decline of
approximately 31%. Nevertheless, the index remains up 37.7% for the year.
These developments suggest that the AI investment boom, the
major support for economic growth and equity markets in 2026, is entering a
pause.
The Magnificent Seven, on an equal-weighted basis, have
gained only 3.81% so far in 2026, compared with a 10.42% gain in the S&P
500, plus approximately 80 basis points in dividends. This divergence reflects
a rotation away from the largest technology stocks and toward other market
sectors, including Walmart and Costco, which have benefited from expectations
surrounding Christmas shopping.
The message is clear: technology leadership has weakened,
AI-related spending and valuations are facing greater scrutiny, and the
market's advance is becoming increasingly dependent on sectors outside the
major technology companies.
In this environment, Doug Casey's prediction of a much deeper
economic downturn next year looks like a reasonable possibility.
7. Overall Market Outlook: An Extraordinary Concentration of
Risks
In my personal experience, I have never seen such a vast
array of major economic and financial risks aligned so heavily in one
direction. I put the probability of a
U.S. recession at 99% in 2027.
The two developments that could substantially change this
outlook would be an end to the Iran war through a U.S. withdrawal, effectively
accepting defeat, or a major reversal in Federal Reserve policy. I consider
both possibilities remote at this point. Either development could trigger a
substantial stock-market rally.
Oil prices may also remain elevated despite any eventual
peace agreement. The rebuilding of depleted inventories will create additional
demand, making it difficult for prices to decline significantly. At this stage,
a change in the political situation might improve market psychology, but it
would not necessarily reverse the underlying economic and supply-demand
dynamics.
The central issue for investors is whether the current
weakness in U.S. bonds, commodities, precious metals, housing, and technology
stocks is merely a correction or the beginning of a much broader economic and
financial contraction.
End Quotes:
Is there any hope? - Victor
Sperandeo.
This nation will remain the land of the free only so long as
it is the home of the brave." - News broadcaster and writer Elmer Davis (January 13, 1890 May 18, 1958).
.
Wishing you good health,
success and good luck. Till next
time
..
The Curmudgeon
ajwdct@gmail.com
Follow the Curmudgeon on Twitter @ajwdct247
Curmudgeon is a retired investment professional. He has been involved in financial markets since 1968 (yes, he cut his teeth on the 1968-1974 bear market), became an SEC Registered Investment Advisor in 1995, and received the Chartered Financial Analyst designation from AIMR (now CFA Institute) in 1996. He managed hedged equity and alternative (non-correlated) investment accounts for clients from 1992-2005.
Victor Sperandeo is a historian, economist and financial innovator who has re-invented himself and the companies he's owned (since 1971) to profit in the ever-changing and arcane world of markets, economies, and government policies. Victor started his Wall Street career in 1966 and began trading for a living in 1968. As President and CEO of Alpha Financial Technologies LLC, Sperandeo oversees the firm's research and development platform, which is used to create innovative solutions for different futures markets, risk parameters and other factors.
Copyright ฉ 2026 by the Curmudgeon and Marc Sexton. All rights reserved.
Readers are PROHIBITED from duplicating, copying, or reproducing article(s) written by The Curmudgeon and Victor Sperandeo without providing the URL of the original posted article(s).